As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. How this site makes money
Wine & SpiritsAccessories · Cellar Provisions
Recipes · Home bar

Unconventional mixers: because cola is too mainstream

Five homemade mixers that take ten minutes and make a plain highball taste like a bar menu, plus the tools that make them easy.

Updated Nov 20265 min readFiled under Home Bar
A moody bar scene at night with a drink
Photo: Jesse Hauck / Pexels

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. If you buy through the links below, this site may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. We haven’t lab-tested these products; notes summarize owner reviews and named publications. $ marks are rough price tiers, so check today’s price on Amazon.

I · The short versionQuick picks

No.Pick
1Cucumber in a bottleMonin cucumber syrup $$$$Check price on Amazon ↗
2Shake them rightBartender kit with stand $$$$Check price on Amazon ↗
3Smoke the bourbon oneSmokeTop cocktail smoker $$$$Check price on Amazon ↗
4Big upgrade: nugget iceGE Profile Opal 2.0 $$$$Check price on Amazon ↗

II · Five mixersFive mixers that beat cola

01 Cucumber-mint

Muddle a few cucumber slices and mint leaves, or use Monin cucumber syrup for a shortcut. Top a gin highball with soda for a cooler G&T.

02 Ginger-lemongrass

Simmer sliced ginger and bruised lemongrass in simple syrup for 10 minutes, then strain. It’s great with dark rum and soda.

03 Pineapple-basil

Blend pineapple, strain, and shake it with torn basil. Use it in place of triple sec in a margarita.

04 Blackberry-sage

Muddle blackberries with a sage leaf and a little syrup. It’s a natural match for bourbon. Add a wisp of wood smoke and it’s a dinner-party drink.

05 Chai spice

Steep a chai tea bag in hot simple syrup. With vodka and a splash of cream it tastes like a grown-up chai latte.

III · The gearTools that make homemade mixers easy

No. 01 / 03Small gift

Small giftBartender kit with stand

A shaker, jigger, strainer and muddler are everything the recipes above need. Read the current listing for exactly what’s included.

No. 02 / 03Mid-range

Mid-rangeMiddleton Mixology SmokeTop smoker kit

Wood smoke over the blackberry-sage bourbon drink.

What owners say · In owner reviews of smoker kits, cheap bundled torches are the most common failure. Chip flavor varies, and resin builds up over time.

No. 03 / 03Splurge

SplurgeGE Profile Opal 2.0 nugget ice maker

Fruity, muddled drinks are better over nugget ice.

What owners say · Owners love the ice but say to use distilled water and clean the hidden tank, or it screeches and grows mold. Expect a two- to three-year lifespan.

IV · Asked oftenFAQ

How long do homemade syrups keep?

Most keep about two weeks in a sealed jar in the fridge. Toss any that look cloudy.

Can I make these alcohol-free?

Yes. Every mixer here works with soda water alone.

Keep reading: Bar carts & cabinets · 10 things every home bar needs · The bar spoon